A man charged with breaching barring orders obtained by his mother had to be removed from a courtroom by prison officers after he became verbally abusive while personally cross-examining her during a bail application. Our criminal defence solicitors act for clients in the District Court, Circuit Court and Central Criminal Court, much of it under the criminal legal aid scheme.
No solicitor available
Cross-examination in such a situation would ordinarily be conducted by a lawyer, but none was available because of the criminal legal aid dispute. The incident occurred at Dublin District Court on Friday, days after it was reported that a woman had been cross-examined during another bail application by her former partner, who gardaí say threatened to rape and kill her.
Domestic violence and rape crisis support organisations have expressed shock at these situations and have called on solicitors involved in the withdrawal of services to make an exception and provide cover in such cases.
What happened in court
The man, who is in his twenties, is awaiting trial on a variety of charges including hijacking a vehicle, burglary and possession of a controlled drug. He has previous convictions for breaching barring orders obtained against him by his mother. He had been on bail, which was revoked following the latest alleged breach.
He was given the opportunity to apply for bail again on Friday, with his mother appearing as an objecting witness. As he had no solicitor, he was permitted to cross-examine her in the interests of justice. The hearing was abandoned and he was removed from the courtroom after he became abusive towards his mother and the judge.
Custody and children's cases now affected
The dispute escalated at the start of this week, with solicitors in several counties withdrawing all criminal defence services. Until then, most practitioners taking part in the action had continued to act where a client was in custody or where a case involved a minor. The withdrawal now extends to custody cases and cases involving children.
Four teenagers facing serious charges, including rape and sexual assault, appeared at the Dublin Children's Court on Monday without solicitors acting for them, although all were eligible for legal aid. They were granted bail on conditions sought by gardaí, and the judge told each of them that getting legal advice was essential. None has entered a plea.
Half of the rape and sexual assault trials due to go ahead at the Central Criminal Court were also disrupted. The presiding judge, Mr Justice Paul McDermott, said the position was regrettable and that solicitors could not unilaterally withdraw where a defendant is in custody, and would have to apply to the court if they wished to do so. He said it was his view that this should not be happening, but that trying to force cases on may create other problems.
Tony Collier on the escalation
Tony Collier of Ferrys Solicitors said practitioners taking part in the action hoped the escalation would bring about meaningful engagement by the Minister with the Law Society. He said there had been little take-up of the new payment model, a position disputed by the Minister.
How the payment model works
Since the new model was introduced on July 1, a flat fee of €520 applies to every legally aided District Court case, irrespective of the number of hearings involved. It replaced a system under which solicitors received approximately €240 for a first appearance and €60 for each subsequent date.
The Minister, Jim O'Callaghan, has said the previous model incentivised adjournments and was open to abuse. Practitioners say the new system is unworkable, that the flat fee does not adequately compensate them in longer than average cases, and that it fails to recognise situations where an accused appears facing multiple charges arising from different incidents on different dates.
The Minister has made some concessions, including increasing the flat fee from €455 to €520 and front-loading it so that solicitors receive two thirds upfront. He has declined to make further concessions and has ruled out mediation while judgment is awaited in the judicial review challenge to the model, which is due on November 3. Speaking this week, he said he would be happy to adjust the regulations if there was a need to do so, but that they would not be revoked.
The Department's figures
According to figures cited by the Department, 177 solicitors have worked under the new model since its introduction, of whom 22 later resigned from the criminal legal aid panel. Around 640 solicitors remain on the panel. Take-up has been strongest in Waterford, Kilkenny, Limerick, Wexford, Cork, Kildare, Clare and Tipperary, and more than 3,400 legal aid certificates have been issued since July 1. Nine solicitors have earned in excess of €50,000 under the scheme and three in excess of €100,000.
The withdrawal of services is largely taking place in Dublin, Wicklow, Meath, Louth, Cavan, Monaghan, Donegal, Roscommon, Leitrim, Sligo, Galway, Mayo, Kerry and Cork.
Where the dispute stands
The chairman of the Oireachtas Justice Committee, Matt Carthy, said the Minister had dug himself into a hole and that it would not have taken much to avoid the dispute. "If Minister O'Callaghan had engaged constructively, this would have been sorted out before it even started," he said. The Minister had earlier told the committee that rape cases were the only cases deliberately affected, a claim solicitors have rejected.
Read the full original report here: Irish Independent