Criminal defence solicitors have escalated their withdrawal of legal aid services to almost all cases, including those involving people in custody and private law matters, in a move that will increase disruption across the courts. Our criminal defence solicitors act for clients in the District Court, Circuit Court and Central Criminal Court, much of it under the criminal legal aid scheme.
The letter to the court presidents
The court presidents were informed in a letter sent on Friday, October 16, that the escalation arose from the failure of the Minister for Justice to engage in meaningful discussions in the dispute over the new legal aid payment model for the District Courts.
The letter was sent by Tony Collier, a partner in Ferrys Solicitors LLP, and is believed to reflect the position of a substantial number of defence solicitors. It followed meetings held by Dublin-based solicitors and solicitors countrywide in the preceding days.
Custody cases now included
Until this point, the withdrawal of services had not affected cases involving people who were in custody before July 1, when the new single flat-fee payment model was introduced. Under the escalation, custody cases and all other cases are affected, with very limited exceptions. That includes protocol cases and cases involving young or vulnerable defendants, victims and witnesses.
The judiciary's call for a resolution
In the letter, Mr Collier referred to comments made in early October by the Chief Justice, who expressed the judiciary's concern at the continuing dispute and his hope for a resolution. He also noted comments by High Court judge Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty encouraging a resolution of the legal challenge to the new payment model. That challenge, taken by Dublin solicitor John Quinn in late July, is due for judgment on November 3.
Mr Collier said the Law Society remains ready to engage with the Minister at a moment's notice. He noted that Mr Quinn had also written to the Minister seeking a meeting but had received no substantive response.
"Regrettable and difficult to comprehend"
He said there remains no indication that the Minister is willing to enter into meaningful discussions aimed at resolving the dispute, and described that as both regrettable and difficult to comprehend.
Mr Collier said the solicitors' profession has made substantial concessions in an effort to resolve the dispute, with only two relatively straightforward issues still outstanding. He said those issues are nonetheless fundamental to the proper administration of justice in the District Court.
In those circumstances, he said he regretted to advise that his firm would, from Monday, withdraw all criminal defence services, including custody cases, in Dublin and nationally. He said the escalation is not due to any unwillingness on the part of solicitors to resolve the dispute, but is a consequence of the Minister's failure to engage in meaningful discussions.
Thousands of cases adjourned
The action has already led to the adjournment of thousands of cases, compounding existing backlogs and delays. While some solicitors have resumed legal aid work and others never took part in the withdrawal, most practitioners, particularly in Dublin, are understood to be continuing with the action.
The payment model provides for a single fee of €520, based on an average of five court appearances, irrespective of the number of charges or court appearances involved. Solicitors say this means they will not be paid for their work in more complex cases, including those involving children and people with addiction and mental health difficulties.
The Department's response
In a statement, the Department of Justice said an 8 per cent increase in criminal legal aid fees payable to solicitors and barristers in the Circuit and higher courts from July 1 represented a total restoration of the fees cut during the financial crisis, and that it is unnecessary and regrettable that some solicitors are choosing this course of action. It said more than 150 solicitors across the country are actively working the new system, with more than 3,000 certificates issued, to an approximate total value of more than €1.5 million since July 1.
Read the full original report here: The Irish Times